Treasure Isle Care Center

Treasure Isle Care Center holds an overall 3-star rating from CMS, which puts it right at average among nursing homes nationwide. That overall score is a composite of three separate ratings, and in this case, those pieces tell pretty different stories depending on what you look at.

The standout here is the 5-star Quality Measures rating, which is as high as it gets. This score is based on 15 clinical indicators tracking things like how residents are managing with pain, mobility, infections, and other health outcomes, so it suggests the facility is doing well where it arguably matters most: the day-to-day physical wellbeing of residents. Staffing comes in at 3 stars, meaning the number of nursing hours per resident is around the national average, which is neither a red flag nor a reason to feel especially reassured. The area that gives the most pause is the 2-star Health Inspection rating, which is below average and reflects citations found during state inspections. That could mean surveyors identified issues with care practices, safety, or facility conditions. Families would do well to dig into the details of those inspection reports, which are publicly available, to understand what was cited and whether the facility has taken steps to address those concerns.

Treasure Isle Care Center staffs more registered nurses than most Florida nursing homes, with residents receiving about 0.68 RN hours per day compared to the state average of 0.52. In practical terms, that means a bit more time with a higher-credentialed nurse who can assess changing conditions, manage medications, and make clinical decisions. However, when you look at total nursing hours across all staff levels, including aides and licensed practical nurses, the picture shifts. Residents here receive around 3.34 total nurse hours per day, which falls below the Florida average of 3.87. For families, that gap is worth thinking about in concrete terms: it can translate to slightly longer waits for help with meals, mobility, or personal care during busy shifts. Neither number tells the whole story on its own, so it helps to visit the facility, observe the floor during a meal or shift change, and ask staff directly about their typical caseloads.

Treasure Isle Care Center has a below-average health inspection rating of 2 out of 5 stars, which tells you that state inspectors have found more concerns here than at a typical facility. That said, the center has no government penalties on record and has never been fined, meaning that while inspections have turned up issues, nothing rose to the level where regulators felt the need to take formal action. Families should treat the low inspection rating as a reason to look closer and ask questions during a tour, but it does not indicate a facility with a history of serious violations or financial penalties. You can compare this facility's record against others in North Bay Village on the North Bay Village nursing homes and assisted living page.

1. How many residents does each certified nursing aide care for during the day shift, and does that number change at night or on weekends?
2. How long have most of your nursing aides and charge nurses been working here, and what does your staff turnover look like over the past year?
3. If my loved one has a fall or a sudden change in condition, what happens in the next hour, and who contacts our family and how quickly?
4. Can you walk me through what a typical Tuesday looks like for a resident who needs help with meals, bathing, and getting around?
5. How do you handle a situation where a resident or family member reports a complaint about a staff member or the quality of care they are receiving?
6. What does your most recent state inspection report say, and where can I read the full findings for myself?

"For more guidance on evaluating facilities, see our guide to questions to ask when choosing a Florida nursing home."