Florida Eldercare Hub

Medicare and Medicaid · Sarasota County

Birchwood Health And Rehabilitation Center

3250 12TH ST, Sarasota, FL 34237 · 9413654185

Overall rating

2/5

Birchwood Health And Rehabilitation Center is a for-profit nursing home in Sarasota, FL with 87 licensed beds. CMS rates it 2 out of 5 stars overall — below average for Florida nursing homes. Subcategory scores: staffing (2/5), health inspections (2/5), quality measures (4/5). The facility has incurred $49,680 in government fines — review the penalty history below.

Are you the owner or manager of this facility?

Claim your profile to respond to families, update your listing, and unlock featured placement.

Claim This Profile →
Birchwood Health And Rehabilitation Center exterior
Birchwood Health And Rehabilitation Center exterior

Not sure if this is the right fit?

A senior care advisor can help you compare options - free, no obligation.

Get help →

How this home is rated

Health Inspection2/5
Staffing2/5
Quality Measures4/5

Source: CMS Care Compare, last updated May 1, 2026

About this home

Capacity
87 beds
Ownership
For profit - Corporation
Type
Medicare and Medicaid
County
Sarasota

Government Penalties

$49,680 total fines
  • 2023-08-17Fine · $49,680

What the government rating says

2

out of 5

CMS stars

Birchwood Health And Rehabilitation Center carries a 2-star CMS rating — below average for Florida. Families considering this facility should review the inspection history, staffing data, and any penalty record carefully before visiting.

Health Inspections

2/5

Below average — notable inspection findings

Staffing

2/5

Below average — fewer nurse hours per resident than typical

Quality Measures

4/5

Good — above-average resident outcomes

What the Ratings Mean

Birchwood Health And Rehabilitation Center holds an overall 2-star rating from CMS, which places it below average compared to other nursing homes nationwide. That overall score is shaped by three separate ratings, and two of them are pulling the number down. The health inspection rating of 2 stars reflects that state inspectors found a higher-than-average number of citations, or more serious ones, during their visits. That's worth paying attention to, because inspection findings often point to real day-to-day care and safety concerns. The staffing rating is also 2 stars, meaning nurses and aides are caring for more residents per shift than the average facility, which can affect how quickly your loved one gets attention and hands-on care.

The one bright spot here is the quality measures rating of 4 stars, which is above average. This score looks at 15 clinical outcomes like rates of falls, pressure sores, and hospitalizations, so it suggests residents are doing reasonably well on measurable health indicators. That's a genuinely positive signal. Still, the overall 2-star picture means families should go in with open eyes. The gap between the quality outcomes score and the lower inspection and staffing scores is something worth asking the facility directly about during a tour, particularly how they handle staffing on nights and weekends and what steps they've taken in response to past inspection findings.

Staffing at a Glance

Staffing at Birchwood Health And Rehabilitation Center runs a bit below what you'd typically see across Florida nursing homes. Residents here receive about 3.31 total nurse hours per day, compared to the Florida average of 3.87, and RN coverage comes in at 0.49 hours per resident daily versus the state average of 0.52. In practical terms, that gap in total nurse hours means the nursing staff at Birchwood is covering more ground per shift, which can affect how quickly someone gets help with daily needs, pain management, or a sudden change in condition. The RN difference is smaller, but registered nurses are the ones making clinical decisions, so even modest gaps can matter when a resident needs careful monitoring. These numbers don't tell the whole story on their own, since a well-organized team can still deliver solid care, but it's a reasonable question to raise with the facility when you visit.

Inspection & Penalty History

Birchwood Health And Rehabilitation Center has a 2-out-of-5-star health inspection rating from the government, which is below average and worth taking seriously. The facility has one recorded federal penalty on the books, resulting in a fine of $49,680, with the most recent penalty issued in August 2023. A single penalty doesn't automatically mean a facility is unsafe, but a fine of this size paired with a below-average inspection rating suggests families should ask pointed questions about what happened, what corrective steps were taken, and how care standards have improved since then. It's reasonable to request more details before making a decision. Families evaluating this facility can compare it to others in Sarasota on the Sarasota nursing homes and assisted living page.

Questions to Ask When You Visit
  1. How many residents does each certified nursing assistant care for during the day shift, and how does that change at night and on weekends?
  2. How long have your current nurses and aides been working here, and what does your staff turnover look like over the past year?
  3. If my family member falls or has a medical emergency overnight, who responds, how quickly, and how will you contact me?
  4. Can I visit at any time without calling ahead, and are there any hours or areas of the building where family members are not allowed?
  5. What does a typical Tuesday look like for a resident who doesn't have therapy scheduled, and how do you make sure they aren't just sitting alone in their room?
  6. Has this facility received any state or federal citations in the past two years, and if so, what did you change as a result?

For more guidance on evaluating facilities, see our guide to questions to ask when choosing a Florida nursing home.

Is your loved one a Florida veteran?

VA benefits can significantly reduce the cost of nursing home and assisted living care in Florida — and many families don't realize they may qualify.

Learn how VA benefits work →

Not sure yet?

Talk to someone who can help

You don't have to figure this out alone. A placement specialist will reach out to walk you through your options — at no cost, no pressure.

Facility you're asking about

Birchwood Health And Rehabilitation Center

Only your name and phone are required — fill in the rest if you have it.

We may pass your details to a trusted placement specialist who can help. You decide who you talk to and when — no pressure.