Florida Eldercare Hub

Medicare and Medicaid · Sarasota County

Siesta Key Health And Rehabilitation Center

4602 NORTHGATE COURT, Sarasota, FL 34234 · 9413552913

Overall rating

3/5

Siesta Key Health And Rehabilitation Center is a for-profit nursing home in Sarasota, FL with 120 licensed beds. CMS rates it 3 out of 5 stars overall — average for Florida nursing homes. Subcategory scores: staffing (4/5), health inspections (3/5), quality measures (4/5). The facility has incurred $317,977 in government fines — review the penalty history below.

Are you the owner or manager of this facility?

Claim your profile to respond to families, update your listing, and unlock featured placement.

Claim This Profile →
Siesta Key Health And Rehabilitation Center exterior
Siesta Key Health And Rehabilitation Center exterior

Not sure if this is the right fit?

A senior care advisor can help you compare options - free, no obligation.

Get help →

How this home is rated

Health Inspection3/5
Staffing4/5
Quality Measures4/5

Source: CMS Care Compare, last updated May 1, 2026

About this home

Capacity
120 beds
Ownership
For profit - Limited Liability company
Type
Medicare and Medicaid
County
Sarasota

Government Penalties

$317,977 total fines
  • 2023-08-06Fine · $317,977
  • 2023-08-06Payment Denial

What the government rating says

3

out of 5

CMS stars

Siesta Key Health And Rehabilitation Center holds a 3-star CMS rating — average for a Florida nursing home. The facility meets federal requirements but does not rank in the top tier. The sub-category breakdown below shows where it performs well and where there is room for improvement.

Health Inspections

3/5

Average inspection results

Staffing

4/5

Good — above-average nurse hours per resident

Quality Measures

4/5

Good — above-average resident outcomes

What the Ratings Mean

Siesta Key Health And Rehabilitation Center holds an overall 3-star rating from CMS, which places it in the average range compared to other nursing facilities nationwide. That overall score is a composite of three separate ratings, and in this case, two of those three areas actually stand out as strengths. The staffing rating comes in at 4 stars, meaning residents here receive above-average nursing hours relative to the number of people being cared for, which is a meaningful indicator of how much hands-on attention staff can realistically provide. The quality measures rating is also 4 stars, reflecting above-average performance across 15 clinical benchmarks that track real resident health outcomes, things like how well the facility manages pain, prevents infections, or maintains residents' physical functioning.

Where the facility lands at average is in health inspections, which also carries a 3-star rating. That score reflects the number and seriousness of citations state inspectors have issued during their on-site visits, and a 3 here means the facility's inspection record is on par with the typical nursing home, not a red flag, but not a standout either. Because health inspections tend to carry significant weight in how CMS calculates the overall score, the average inspection result pulls the composite down to 3 stars even though staffing and clinical outcomes are both above average. For families, that context matters. The day-to-day care environment and resident health outcomes appear stronger than the overall number might first suggest.

Staffing at a Glance

Staffing at Siesta Key Health And Rehabilitation Center runs a bit below what you'd typically see across Florida nursing homes. Residents here receive about 3.52 total nurse hours per day, compared to the Florida average of 3.87, and registered nurse coverage comes in at 0.47 hours per resident daily versus the state average of 0.52. In practical terms, that gap might not sound like much on paper, but spread across a full day it can mean nurses and aides are stretched a little thinner, with slightly less one-on-one time available for each resident. It does not necessarily mean care is inadequate, but if your loved one has complex medical needs or requires close monitoring, it is worth asking the facility how they manage staffing during nights, weekends, and busy periods before making a decision.

Inspection & Penalty History

Siesta Key Health And Rehabilitation Center has received two government penalties, with total fines adding up to $317,977, and the most recent penalty was issued in August 2023. That is a significant dollar amount, and the fact that a penalty occurred recently is worth paying attention to. The facility's health inspection rating sits at 3 out of 5 stars, which is middle-of-the-road. None of this means the facility is necessarily the wrong choice, but families should go in with eyes open, ask the facility directly about what led to those penalties, and find out what steps were taken to address the problems. Families evaluating this facility can compare it to others in Sarasota on the Sarasota nursing homes and assisted living page.

Questions to Ask When You Visit
  1. How many residents does each certified nursing aide typically care for during the day shift, and does that number change at night or on weekends?
  2. How long have your nursing staff members been working here on average, and what does your turnover rate look like over the past year?
  3. If my loved one has a concern or a bad night, who specifically will I be able to reach, and how quickly can I expect a call back?
  4. Can you walk me through what a typical weekday looks like for a resident who is not enrolled in therapy, from the time they wake up until they go to bed?
  5. How do you handle situations where a resident's condition changes quickly, and can you give me a real example of how that process worked recently?
  6. What does your most recent state inspection report show, and where can I read the full results along with any deficiencies that were cited?

"For more guidance on evaluating facilities, see our guide to questions to ask when choosing a Florida nursing home."

Is your loved one a Florida veteran?

VA benefits can significantly reduce the cost of nursing home and assisted living care in Florida — and many families don't realize they may qualify.

Learn how VA benefits work →

Not sure yet?

Talk to someone who can help

You don't have to figure this out alone. A placement specialist will reach out to walk you through your options — at no cost, no pressure.

Facility you're asking about

Siesta Key Health And Rehabilitation Center

Only your name and phone are required — fill in the rest if you have it.

We may pass your details to a trusted placement specialist who can help. You decide who you talk to and when — no pressure.